Atheist Logic Fail

learn2science

Lolwut!!!

8 Comments

ImageImage

The Jews did Hellenize and they absorbed the Greek culture and philosophy, Rome became Christian, and the Roman Empire became the Roman Catholic Church, those are facts.  But here is the Question…

Image

Let us use the faculty of our reason, at one time India had a single goddess that they worshiped, and then the northern people invaded and there was an explosion of culture, literature, music, architecture, gods, polytheism, the “Norsemen” were polytheists with a rich culture of music culture, and literature, so how did that turn into a religion that despises art, literature, and even alcohol?  Remember the Norsemen told fables, sung of valor and victory, and drank ale. 

 ImageImage

 

Advertisements

Author: Joxua Luxor

Known by his online handle Shivah Solomon, he paints as Joxua Mourningstar, he teaches Martial Tai Chi as Master Ten Ton Tiger, writing on occult mysteries he is known as Rabbi Ba'al Shiva, he writes philosophical fiction as Shivastus Solomonicus, and he does comedy as Adam Wolfe.

8 thoughts on “Lolwut!!!

  1. …what?

    This post has achieved the status of ‘not even wrong’. Norsemen did not invade India, Aryans did. The historical Aryan people have absolutely nothing to do with Nazism. Putting a swastika next to Dawkins is just pathetic on your part. Aryans were a pastoralist Bronze Age people who originated in the area of the Iranian Plateau and southern Russia. The people of the Indus Valley Civilisation left no writing that we’ve deciphered and we therefore know little of their religion. There’s no reason to think they worshipped a single goddess. The hybrid culture produced by the Aryan invasion is the ancestor of today’s Hinduism, it has nothing to do with Islam.

    Seriously, the breadth and depth of ignorance displayed here is truly astounding.

  2. Regardless of the historical data you present, whether it’s right or wrong the structure of your argument is messed up. To begin, categorizing all historians of religion as “Nazi Scientists” is already the biggest red light for any logical person to spot out. Secondly you talk about atheist fallacies but right here you’ve already screwed yourself over with: Guilt by association. “Oh! The Nazi’s notice an evolution in human religion! And Richard Dawkins also noticed it as well… Ergo Richard Dawkins is automatically a Nazi!” assuming your atrociously wrong claim about ‘All historians of religion are nazi scientists’ is hypothetically true.

    So all in one big blow you’ve already toppled over the very argument I can estimate is that ‘Richard Dawkins is a fraud’.

    To add salt to the wound when responding to Erasmus, I don’t care how much knowledge you have about “proto-Indo-European(s)”, if the foundation of the argument you propose is incredibly bad, no amount of outside knowledge will fix that. You also refute Erasmus’ argument by saying “You’re arguing about known fact that I cherry pick which means you’re a doodoo head and therefore your argument is null”

    So all in one big blow you’ve already toppled over the very argument I can estimate is that ‘Richard Dawkins is a fraud’.

    To add salt to the wound when responding to Erasmus, I don’t care how much you claim to have knowledge you have about “proto-Indo-European(s)”, if the foundation of the argument you propose is incredibly bad, no amount of outside knowledge will fix that. You also refute Erasmus’ argument by saying “You’re arguing about known fact that I merely claim without evidence which means you’re a doodoo head and therefore your argument is null”. First off, you seriously want to see who’s right I’d love to see you pull up solid evidence to support the claims you call “facts” and no, The Bible doesn’t count as solid evidence.

  3. Regardless of the historical data you present, whether it’s right or wrong the structure of your argument is messed up. To begin, categorizing all historians of religion as “Nazi Scientists” is already the biggest red light for any logical person to spot out. Secondly you talk about atheist fallacies but right here you’ve already screwed yourself over with: Guilt by association. “Oh! The Nazi’s notice an evolution in human religion! And Richard Dawkins also noticed it as well… Ergo Richard Dawkins is automatically a Nazi!” assuming your atrociously wrong claim about ‘All historians of religion are nazi scientists’ is hypothetically true.

    So all in one big blow you’ve already toppled over the very argument I can estimate is that ‘Richard Dawkins is a fraud’.

    To add salt to the wound when responding to Erasmus, I don’t care how much knowledge you have about “proto-Indo-European(s)”, if the foundation of the argument you propose is incredibly bad, no amount of outside knowledge will fix that. You also refute Erasmus’ argument by saying “You’re arguing about known fact that I cherry pick which means you’re a doodoo head and therefore your argument is null”

    So all in one big blow you’ve already toppled over the very argument I can estimate is that ‘Richard Dawkins is a fraud’.

    To add salt to the wound when responding to Erasmus, I don’t care how much knowledge you claim to have about “proto-Indo-European(s)”, if the foundation of the argument you propose is incredibly bad, no amount of outside knowledge will fix that. You also refute Erasmus’ argument by saying “You’re arguing about known fact that I merely claim without evidence which means you’re a doodoo head and therefore your argument is null”. First off, you seriously want to see who’s right I’d love to see you pull up solid evidence to support the claims you call “facts” and no, The Bible doesn’t count as solid evidence.

    • I did not conflate all Religious Historians with Nazi Scientists, Idiot. Stop making yourself look stupid.

    • You are presupposing your authority on the bible, an authority you wouldn’t be able to demonstrate with me in a debate. I would bet money you haven’t even heard the term, “Jewish Exegesis” let alone are you an expert at understanding it.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s